DEAR SIR: Does the existing ICBF genetics system work? For any system to work, it must show results and be useful, not just user-friendly. If the system was compiled using factual information such as the actual dimensions, back fat score and weight, then you have the information to work on.

This digitised system exists (see www.ingenera.ch) which will collect the information digitally. Linear scoring is a visual assessment which is subject to the eye of the scorer, therefore, has a human reliability factor.

The Irish Limousin Society entered into a legally binding agreement with ICBF which provided an opt-out clause if the system designed by ICBF, in the opinion of the breeders, was not a tool that could be used to identify better cattle.

If a breeder examined the current system does it identify better cattle? Limousin breeders have a proven record with commercial farmers. Let’s change the current ICBF programme to include the above factual information and get it useable before the money runs out.