Farmers hoping that last Saturday’s publication of EU member states’ draft position on EU budget plans could bring reprieve from slashed ringfenced funding for CAP will have been disappointed by the document published by the Irish presidency of the Council of the EU.

The draft position paper backs the European Commission’s reduction of around a quarter in EU-funded ringfenced CAP funds from 2028, leaving €293.7bn allocated to agriculture out of a total budget of €1.82 trillion.

Leading MEPs had been pushing for approximately €440bn of a CAP budget and farming organisations called for a higher €500bn allocation.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Irish text axes 8% off Brussels’ initially proposed overall spending pot across all programmes to a level that would still leave the next EU budget approximately 30% larger than the current budget, although a chunk of this increase will fund the repayment of EU COVID-19 stimulus borrowings.

Attempt

The text forms the Irish Government’s attempt to reconcile the two broad groups member states have divided into on EU spending reform, but neither seem convinced by the compromise.

The six ‘frugal’ contributor member states that are seeking hundreds of billions in EU spending reductions in the face of political and financial pressure in their home countries say not enough has been cut, while those looking for an even larger budget were expecting areas like CAP to have received a funding boost.

Minister of State for European Affairs Thomas Byrne stated that Government views the text as one that “protected to an extent that the member states wished the traditional policies of the EU” but that also “looked very much to the future” and a need for economic resilience.

Draft

The draft position will be debated by member states with the clock in many influential countries counting down to general elections over the coming 12 months.

Opposition parties in the likes of France and Germany are calling for even more drastic reductions in their contribution to the EU budget than are currently being sought by the six frugals.

Moves by the Commission to re-direct some unallocated EU funds towards agriculture and rural areas have been sold to member states and MEPs as a means of closing the approximately 22% EU funding gap CAP is expected to face amid the reduction in ringfenced funding.

However, there have been fears that these funds – which non-farming programmes will also be competing for – will be insufficient in filling the funding shortfall.