Almost 25,000 farmers applied to join the Beef Data Genomics Programme (BDGP) by close of play yesterday, the original deadline for applications. As we reported in last week’s Irish Farmers Journal a one week extension has been granted with the scheme now closing on Friday 5 June. While the extension is welcome, the problem was never the closing date.

Since the details of the scheme were launched, farmers have expressed very genuine concerns around various conditions relating to the programme. Thousands didn’t turn out at meetings across the country for a scheme which will deliver €52m per annum. We are likely to see large crowds once again at the IFA meeting organised for this Tuesday evening in Mayo.

The IFA have clearly outlined the issues as:

  • The inflexibility of the six year rule

  • The 2014 reference year

  • Young farmers

  • 60% genomic testing and the costs

  • Replacement requirements

  • Penalties

    • The solutions being offered include:

  • Rolling 2014 reference year

  • Midterm review

  • Access for young farmers

  • Reduction in the level of genomic testing

  • 3 star females and weanlings to be eligible for replacement criteria

  • Removal of the 2013 age limit when calculating herd replacement profile

    • Really the question is what impact will these changes have on the overall outcome of the six year programme? Will it still deliver improved genetic gain and change the direction of beef breeding for the better? The answer is clearly yes.

    In the Irish Farmers Journal we have encouraged farmers to submit an application for the Beef Data and Genomic Programme (BDGP). We will continue to do so ahead of the revised deadline. Change is needed within the sector in order to address breeding inefficiencies which are draining money from farmers’ pockets.

    However, Minister for Agriculture Simon Coveney must realise that by ignoring what is happening on the ground, he is running the risk of allowing what could be a great scheme being derailed. While there may be political issues around some of the changes required, the Minister’s priority must be to ensure the programme works for farmers and not just Brussels.