The butter row between Tirlan and Ornua could be the catalyst to increase discussion within dairy circles on future mergers or collaborations, according to former Ornua CEO Kevin Lane.
Stating that while the Irish dairy industry has a good reputation, he cautioned that there is a need for it to think differently and at a greater pace.
Contributing from the floor at the 'Getting Irish dairy on the right path for success' session at Dairy Day 2026 in UL, he said: “The industry has reached a tipping point and I think there is an opportunity here to look at things differently or faster – or both.
"I think the Tirlan/ Ornua spat has shone a light on something that needs to be addressed, but it has to be addressed in a way that is inclusive."
He added: “I think people mustn’t forget that for over 30 years, 100s of millions of euro has been invested in the Kerrygold brand. It is recognised worldwide.
'Incredible brand'
"The job that it does displaying the competencies of the Irish dairy industry and anything we do as in industry, collectively, to undermine that incredible brand and those 100s of millions that have been invested in it, people really need to take stock and now is the time for action.”
After a decade where the Irish milk pool expanded significantly, he said it now has to plan for a situation where the milk pool is unlikely to grow.
“People really need to take stock and now is the time for action and it’s not just those two companies but, the industry, at a time where the milk isn’t growing, probably isn’t likely to grow, only two things matter.
"The costs – the overheads – and the efficiencies and the added value routes to market, more time and effort needs to be put into to try to address whether it's mergers, whether it’s consolidation or whether it’s just collaboration. We need an awful lot more of them and we need them now.”
Referring to the fact that 676 farms have stopped growing tillage in the last year, he cautioned the same could happen dairy farms if the sector isn’t careful.
“I think if we’re not careful and we allow this industry to undermine the farmers' returns, we’ll end up here in a few years time with a number of dairy farms going out of business because the returns won’t be there for them.”

