The Irish Natura & Hill Farmers Association has reiterated its strong opposition to the proposed coupling of payments which has been included in the draft CAP plans.
The coupling proposal would result in a “massive linear cut” to payments which extensive farmers would struggle to recoup, the former INHFA leader Colm O’Donnell told a meeting in Bangor Erris, Co Mayo this week.
A uniform per-hectare payment for all applicants under the new Degressive Area-based Income Support (DABIS), which is proposed to replace the current BISS, would offer the best outcome from the CAP talks for extensive farmers, O’Donnell maintained.
O’Donnell, who is the INHFA’s current representative on the CAP Consultative Committee, predicted that many extensive farmers could see their per hectare payment increase if full flattening is delivered.
And this is allowing for the proposed 22-24% cut in agriculture funding under the yet-to-be-agreed EU budget.
These cuts could see farm supports drop by €80bn across the lifetime of the next CAP programme to a total of €300bn.
A number of challenges in the proposals tabled to date were identified by O’Donnell.
These included the dropping of the mandatory status for the Areas of Natural Constraint (ANC) scheme, the proposed coupling of payments, and changes to the definition of a farmer.
In terms of the coupled payments, O’Donnell pointed out that the INHFA is the only farm organisation opposing this.
“The spin around coupling is that it will reward productive farmers, but you can only be as productive as the land you farm,” he pointed out.
In terms of what constitutes a farmer, O’Donnell said INHFA was worried that two options were included in the draft CAP proposals, where there was only one in the past.
One option states that a farmer is an individual “whose principal activity is an agricultural activity”, O’Donnell said.
The second option defines a farmer as somebody whose “principal activity is not agriculture, but who is engaged in a minimum level of agricultural activity”.
“This is the first time that there has been a move to differentiate how you define a farmer and the INHFA took a position where we were against this because it could have an impact where you target payments,” O’Donnell explained.
The INHFA has tabled a compromise single definition to the Department of Agriculture and officials in Brussels, O’Donnell said.
The association is hopeful of some progress on the issue, he added.


