An inspector has rejected suggestions that contamination photographed in a Roscommon milking parlour arose during an inspection, the trial of a Mayo farmer has heard.

Seán Coughlan of Cum, Lahardane, Ballina, Co Mayo, and Coughlan Farming Ltd, for which he is sole director, denies 78 charges connected to animal welfare on a farm at Laragan, Elphin.

Cross-examining Arthur O’Connor, superintending veterinary inspector with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Fergal McMorrow BL, on behalf of Coughlan Farming Ltd, suggested cattle moving through the parlour during the inspection accounted for fresh dung on the components of the milking equipment.

ADVERTISEMENT

He also suggested other milking clusters looked clean but Mr O’Connor disagreed, saying contamination was clearly visible on every cluster in the photograph.

Mr McMorrow challenged his assessment that two dead calves found in a shed with live calves had their eyes sunken in their heads to the extent they were no longer visible. He suggested they could have died that day, and that birds could have eaten their eyes.

Mr O’Connor accepted scavenging could happen quickly, but said he saw no telltale signs of it in this instance.

Mr McMorrow put it to him that Mr Coughlan disputed his description of wet bedding, saying it was bark mulch, and asked whether samples had been taken.

However, Mr O’Connor said he has many years of experience and did not need to take a sample to know the difference between dung and bark mulch.

Mr McMorrow also questioned whether Mr Coughlan’s dispute with the Department over herd registration and movement restrictions had been investigated, but Mr O’Connor said he did not consider the dispute relevant to the conditions in which the animals had been kept.

The trial continues before Judge Kenneth Connolly and a jury at Roscommon Circuit Court. Mr Coughlan, on behalf of himself and of his company, has pleaded not guilty to all charges.