As outlined on p11, the proposal to link participation in a new carbon footprinting project to Farm Sustainability Payments is set to be blocked by Stormont’s agriculture committee.
It is remarkable that some MLAs who championed the most stretching greenhouse gas targets in 2022 when climate change legislation was passed, are now wary of policies that are designed to meet those same targets.
But with the Ulster Farmers’ Union opposed, farmers emailing MLAs in their droves and an Assembly election around the corner, political will for mandatory carbon footprints has waned.
If Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir and Stormont’s agriculture committee remain at loggerheads on the issue, the obvious compromise would be some sort of voluntary carbon audit scheme.
Like the Bovine Genetics Project, registration and training could remain a condition for claiming Farm Sustainability Payments, but actual participation in a carbon audit could be optional.
Rather than scrapping it altogether, keeping the DAERA-led scheme on a voluntary basis would still allow NI to have a consistent approach to carbon audits for those who want to do it.
Indeed, some processors have been vocal in their support for carbon audits, so more farmers could end up participating than we currently think, although it will require the right financial incentives to be put in place.
But carrots and sticks aside, there needs to be greater appreciation of a key reason why many farmers are opposed to carbon audits in the first place – the methodology used for calculating emissions from our farms is flawed.
The GWP100 system for comparing different greenhouse gases does not take into account the short-term nature of methane, which is emitted by ruminants as part of a natural carbon cycle.
It is understandable why a farmer would not want to complete a carbon audit when the numbers appear to be rigged against them to the benefit of the fossil fuel industry.
There are also concerns around how carbon sequestered in soils, trees and hedgerows is categorised, while beyond that, NI agriculture figures are skewed by the fact emissions are based on where food is produced, not consumed. Carbon footprinting also ignores other environmental issues, such as biodiversity and water quality.


