Representatives from Sinn Féin and SDLP have publicly set out opposition to plans which would link a new carbon audit project to farm payments.
The current plan from DAERA is that participation in carbon footprinting will be a condition of the Farm Sustainability Payment from 2029.
For those who do not participate, the proposal is that a 10% payment penalty would apply in the first year, rising to 15% thereafter.
However, Sinn Féin’s agriculture spokesperson Declan McAleer has described the department’s proposals as “very concerning”.
“Proposals to make carbon auditing compulsory is unnecessary and disproportionate and would put a greater burden on smaller farmers,” the West Tyrone MLA said.
McAleer said Sinn Féin supports the option of voluntary carbon footprinting, but is opposed to financial penalties applying for non-participation.
Daniel McCrossan from the SDLP said he had “serious reservations” about making carbon audits compulsory.
“DAERA needs to listen to farmers on the ground, rethink these proposals and give families practical help to cut emissions and improve soil health,” he said.
Blocked
With the DUP and UUP already opposed, the latest interventions from Sinn Féin and SDLP means the proposals will be blocked by Stormont’s agriculture committee.
Despite that, Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir appeared to be still pushing the plan when he spoke in the Assembly chamber on Tuesday.
“We are not requiring people to do something as a result of the carbon footprinting report. We are giving farmers tools so they can reduce their carbon emissions and also [improve] their efficiency and profitability,” he said.
The Alliance MLA said the proposals to make carbon audits a condition for claiming the Farm Sustainability Payment would help justify the budget for the farm support scheme.
“We are delivering significant funding to support our agricultural industry, and rightly so. But we also need to demonstrate value for money and this is one way we can do that,” Minister Muir said.


