Dairy Day returned to the University of Limerick sports arena last weekend and mergers, collaborations, consolidations once again drew a lot of comment, but the atmosphere about the debate felt different.

A year ago, there was talk of the potential upset that could be created with Ornua and Tirlán competing in the same market place, this year it was the consequences of this competition becoming reality that stirred debate.

“We’re undermining our greatest brand. We’re undermining a brand that was built by the generations that went before us. Are we going to be the generation that let it die, destroy it?” said Edward Carr as he questioned why there’s even an attempt to undermine it.

ADVERTISEMENT

The ICOS president and ArraTipp chair didn’t hold back in his comments and called for the Kerrygold brand to be built on, and suggested that maybe whey was the way to do it.

The American perspective brought by Mike McCully certainly shook things up on all fronts.

A dairy sector where milk is the by-product of beef calf production and cheese, the by-product of whey production and with milk only breaking even, the Americans are still driving on.

Equating it to the quota coming off in Europe but at a different level, he reported unprecedented investment in processing, driven largely by the demand for protein, with over 40 new processing plants or expansions developed in recent years.

Dairy cow numbers stateside are at their highest since 1991 and continue to grow, as he gave the example of Minnesota-based Riverview Farms adding three new farms, which will have 45,000 cows between them.

That’s just a snapshot from the US, but it wasn’t all big is better news from McCully as he highlighted the success of smaller co-ops such as Tillamook in Oregan and Tatua in New Zealand.

They have 60 and 101 suppliers/shareholders respectively, but have innovated and thrived in environments where larger dairy entities dominate.

Ireland’s position was summed up by Carbery’s Jason Hawkins, when he said if all Irish milk was put in one plant, you’re barely competing with the US and you’re committing to commodities forever.

Questioning the claims that 2c to 3c/l savings could be made through mergers, he suggested that those gains might be got in time through more focus on value-add.

The subject of consolidation has been a constant one in Irish dairy since the advent of the co-operative movement.

It’s gathering pace and if you view it in milk processing pools we’re there already. Perhaps pooling the milk is the easy part, innovation and research and development are possibly where there is more scope for collaboration.

The same could be said of marketing but as we’ve seen this year, that’s not all plain sailing.