The pathway structure on New Zealand dairy farms is the envy of most dairy farming nations across the world.

Before getting into the weeds of the different steps, it’s important to note that they have much greater scale on farms, which makes this whole process a lot easier.

The average herd size is over 400 cows, which means there is a big enough pie to be shared. This is not the case on a lot of smaller Irish farms; however, there are still lessons to be taken from it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pathway

The typical person enters a business as a farm assistant. They then move on to become a 2IC (second in charge), which is followed by a farm manager or herd manager role on some bigger farms.

After proving themselves as a capable farm manager, the next step is a contract milker. A contract milker is paid a rate per kilo of milk solids and is expected to run the day-to-day operations on the farm, provide all of the labour and some of the light machinery, like bikes or quads. Some contract milkers also provide smaller items like gloves, parlour cleaning products, paper towels, etc.

Following contract milking, the farm owner may offer a role as a sharemilker. Sharemilkers essentially buy into the business in the form of cows and get a percentage of the farm profits. The percentage depends on the agreement.

For sharemilkers, the typical aim is to grow their share up to a 50:50 split. At that stage, they have purchased all of the cows and are responsible for all of the decision-making. They pay a share of most bills and all of the others, like labour and animal health.

After sharemilking for a number of years and building an asset base and some capital, farm ownership is the next likely step.

The steps on the pathway provide an excellent opportunity to learn at different levels of intensity and develop skills along the way.

Not everyone progresses the whole way through, and some will opt to remain as a 2IC or farm manager, while others will be trying to move through the steps as quickly as possible. There’s no right way to do it, and it’s up to the individuals and the farm owners to decide the course of action.

Family

Even children born onto a dairy farm are expected to follow the pathway and earn their stripes.

Naturally, those who are from dairy farms or those individuals who are highly capable may be afforded the luxury of skipping a couple of the steps along the way, but the general rule of thumb is to spend time in each role.

Children of dairy farmers usually end up entering into 50:50 sharemilking arrangements with their parents before buying them out completely, if that’s what the family agrees to.

By purchasing the farm from the parents, it provides a pension pot for the parents but also reduces the level of conflict within families, as there are not as many difficult decisions around handing over the farm to one child versus another.

Contract milkers

While we were there, it seemed that contract milking was the preferred step at the moment. Milk prices were good, so the rate contract milkers were receiving was strong, and as cow prices have doubled in the past three years, many young people have opted not to move on to sharemilking, as the capital required to get started outweighs the reward.

Contract milkers, on the other hand, can start with very little equity or savings. The money they then earn is based on a rate per kilo of milk solids produced. Bigger farms will have slightly lower rates, as the amount of milk produced is far greater than that of smaller farms.

Contract milkers we met were earning in the range of $1.40 up to $1.70/kg MS. This equates to 70c up to 85c/kg MS in Ireland.

From there, it’s up to the contract milker to decide who they employ and how many. If they want to earn more money, they can opt to work more hours and reduce the number of employees, but this can come at a cost. Being understaffed could mean poorer performance and less return, so it’s up to the contract milker to be aware of that.

In an Irish context, on a dairy farm with 200 cows producing 480kg MS/cow, the contract milker on a rate of 85c/kg MS will earn €81,600/year. From there, they will have to pay themselves and probably one full-time employee.

That makes the pot quite small if the second employee is earning, say, €38,000/year. Therefore, in an Irish context, as there isn’t the same scale, the rate will probably need to be closer to €1/kg MS.

This isn’t far away from what the total labour bill on most farms will already be. The added advantage for the farm owner is that the management of the farm is handed over to the contract milker.

Where this arrangement could be very beneficial is on smaller farms where the farm owner is looking to start stepping back but isn’t ready to hand over full control of the business.

Even on a 120-cow farm, for example, if the rate was slightly higher at, say, €1.10/kg MS and 480kg of milk solids were produced per cow, the contract milker would make €63,360. They will likely opt to pay for some relief staff but should still have a good wage themselves.

Detail

If this was a potential option for farms, it’s important to consider the detail when drawing up a contract.

There have to be some non-negotiables within it that the contract milker must adhere to.

As they are getting paid per kilo of milk solids produced, it makes sense for them to produce more milk. If this is done at the expense of feeding more meal, for example, the contract milker will become better off, but the farm owner will suffer as profitability will be eroded.

Other contingencies like mortality rates or breeding performance must be accounted for.

In New Zealand, there are expectations drawn into contracts around fair levels of mortality in cows or youngstock.

There are also limits on empty rates and six-week calving rate performance. The farm owner can’t expect the contract milker to set records every year, but they also can’t allow performance to slip.

All of this detail will be between the two parties to decide, but it should be as fair and equitable as possible for both.

Comment

The big advantage of these arrangements is that young people who are passionate and energetic can get started in their own right, while still having the farm owner or person stepping back to call on if they need advice.

For the farm owner, it creates time freedom and takes away the headaches of recruiting staff while still earning a very good return.

On farms at a big scale or with multiple units, it’s a really good starting point in terms of extracting oneself from the day-to-day technical decisions while still having input and some level of control.

Rates do need to be fair, however, as the contract milker needs to have the advantage of being able to grow more equity than a farm management role would provide. Even €1/kg MS is low in the context of scale on most Irish farms. Labour in Ireland is more expensive than in New Zealand, so don’t rely on the New Zealand figure.

€1.05 to €1.15/kg MS, depending on the size of the farm and what the contract milker is paying for, is probably fairer.

For more information on contract milking, the DairyNZ website has details on what’s involved.