The war in Ukraine has exposed the lack of commitment and foresight that retailers bring to the production of food in the EU. For almost three weeks now, the EU retail sector has ignored the impact of the ongoing conflict on global food security – instead choosing to continue as normal with their “inflation busting” campaigns that are putting the economic viability of so many food producers at risk – particularly within the horticulture sector.

In the past, retailers have tried to position themselves as an integral part of food production, with pictures of “their” farmers draped from the ceilings of stores or plastered across promotional material – clearly an attempt to link them directly to the production of food in the eyes of their consumers.

But their silence and complete lack of willingness to give farmers increased financial security to maintain food production in the face of soaring input costs exposes them for what they are: just another part of the distribution network that, similar to a haulage company, facilitates the movement of food from farmers and food processors to consumers.

ADVERTISEMENT

Plans to support producers

They should not be allowed continue with such a strategy. Instead, the retail sector must be forced to come forward with plans as to how they are going to support EU food producers in the face of a global crisis.

So far, the focus has been on getting farmers to grow more grains and ramp up forage production to ensure adequate feed for livestock next winter. There have been many suggestions put forward and of course there are steps farmers can take. But to date, no one has recognised the scale of the financial risk that farmers – the lowest-margin operators in the supply chain – are being asked to expose their family farms to without any security.

Farmers, as they have proved time and again, have the capacity to quickly increase food production – but they must be given the correct policy landscape and financial security to do so.

Government responsibility

Delivering the policy landscape falls on Government. In recent weeks, we have detailed what policy measures need to be taken in the days (not weeks) ahead to help bring more land into production and increase the productivity of existing lands. But these policy measures will only lead to higher production if farmers are also given the financial security to allow them make the huge investment necessary in securing additional inputs – if and when they are available.

Instead of continuing to engage in a race to the bottom on price, EU retailers could help provide this financial security through the introduction of forward price contracts that deliver margin security to farmer suppliers. Such contracts may well be linked to energy and fertiliser prices or a mix of key farm input costs.

Role of retailers

EU retailers need to realise that in the face of rising global hunger, their consumers will legitimately ask them what role they played in helping prevent increased suffering in the Asia-Pacific region and sub-Saharan Africa – regions of the world where the United Nations FAO is forecasting that an additional seven to 13 million undernourished people will be concentrated. At present, retailers are contributing to the problem by failing to give EU farmers the security needed to ease the pressure on global food markets by maximising food production capacity within the EU.

The view from a farm in Ukraine as Russia continues its invasion of the country.

If action by retailers is not forthcoming, then emergency EU legislation should be considered. The result would be to introduce minimum price contracts for farmers for produce sold off their farms in the years ahead. To do so is not reinventing the wheel. Such mechanisms are already used in California in relation to liquid milk – linking the retail price to farm input costs.

Alternatively, the European Commission should give consideration to increasing the price trigger point for the introduction of public intervention for the main commodities in line with spiralling production costs. The move would effectively introduce a minimum price safety net for farmers selling produce next autumn and force retailers and other market outlets to compete at a price point that reflects farm costs. The overall cost to the EU would be minimal with the intention clearly not being to put food into storage.

Morally reprehensible

Ultimately, the Commission and farmers, through Copa Cogeca, need to turn attention on to EU retailers – in the same way the IFA has here. Relying on the financial strength of the EU to maintain food on shelves by out-competing poorer countries is morally reprehensible. The EU must maximise the food production capacity of its highly fertile land in a bid to help prevent millions of people being forced into food poverty globally. EU retailers cannot be allowed to abdicate their responsibility in supporting EU farmers in this drive.

China well prepared ahead of Russian invasion

Rice terraces in China

All eyes are on China with reports from the US that Beijing has signalled a willingness to provide military assistance to Russia in the ongoing invasion of Ukraine.

If such a development were to materialise, the impact of this war on global food supply chains would be dialled up to a new level. It is a scenario that China has clearly been preparing for, having amassed 50% of world wheat stocks in line with introducing a suspension on fertiliser exports as far back as July 2021 – a year in which LNG imports into the country soared by 17%, making China the largest importer in the world.

While Putin’s invasion of Ukraine took some by surprise, China’s activity on world markets would suggest it was preparing throughout 2021.