Farmer's letter: stark price differences in genotyping
"A suckler farmer will pay €20 a calf for each genotype and a dairy farmer will pay €4 for the exact same genotype test" - Flor McCarthy, Killowen House, Killowen, Kenmare, Co Kerry
At the rate the national suckler herd is reducing, we should be the first to get money out of the EU Brexit Adjustment Reserve fund - and get our calves genotyped for free.
ADVERTISEMENT
DEAR EDITOR: I am calling on Minister Charlie McConalogue, to immediately review the stark differences in charges for genotyping.
Unacceptable costs
It is totally unacceptable that a suckler farmer will pay €600 to genotype his 30 calves, while a dairy farmer with 150 calves can genotype his calves for €600 also.
ADVERTISEMENT
To put this in a simpler form, a suckler farmer will pay €20 a calf/genotype and a dairy farmer will pay €4 for the exact same genotype test.
I seriously question the logic or fairness in this. It is poor reward for beef farmers who have been genotyping their calves for the past six to seven years.
At the rate the national suckler herd is reducing, we should be the first to get money out of the EU Brexit Adjustment Reserve fund and get our calves genotyped for free.
Confidence in ICBF lost
I would go so far as to say that this move has undermined my confidence in the genotyping programme being operated by the Irish Cattle Breeding Federation (ICBF), because if they allow a differential in charges like this to happen, I have serious concerns about the weighting of different traits and if the said results might be more favourable towards the dairy lobby.
I am calling on the IFA rep who sits on the board of the ICBF to state clearly what the IFA’s position is on this.
Register for free to read this story and our free stories.
This content is available to digital subscribers and loyalty code users only. Sign in to your account, use the code or subscribe to get unlimited access.
However, if you would like to share the information in this article, you may use the headline, summary and link below:
Title: Farmer's letter: stark price differences in genotyping
"A suckler farmer will pay €20 a calf for each genotype and a dairy farmer will pay €4 for the exact same genotype test" - Flor McCarthy, Killowen House, Killowen, Kenmare, Co Kerry
The reader loyalty code gives you full access to the site from when you enter it until the following Wednesday at 9pm. Find your unique code on the back page of Irish Country Living every week.
CODE ACCEPTED
You have full access to the site until next Wednesday at 9pm.
CODE NOT VALID
Please try again or contact support.
DEAR EDITOR: I am calling on Minister Charlie McConalogue, to immediately review the stark differences in charges for genotyping.
Unacceptable costs
It is totally unacceptable that a suckler farmer will pay €600 to genotype his 30 calves, while a dairy farmer with 150 calves can genotype his calves for €600 also.
To put this in a simpler form, a suckler farmer will pay €20 a calf/genotype and a dairy farmer will pay €4 for the exact same genotype test.
I seriously question the logic or fairness in this. It is poor reward for beef farmers who have been genotyping their calves for the past six to seven years.
At the rate the national suckler herd is reducing, we should be the first to get money out of the EU Brexit Adjustment Reserve fund and get our calves genotyped for free.
Confidence in ICBF lost
I would go so far as to say that this move has undermined my confidence in the genotyping programme being operated by the Irish Cattle Breeding Federation (ICBF), because if they allow a differential in charges like this to happen, I have serious concerns about the weighting of different traits and if the said results might be more favourable towards the dairy lobby.
I am calling on the IFA rep who sits on the board of the ICBF to state clearly what the IFA’s position is on this.
If you would like to speak to a member of our team, please call us on 01-4199525.
Link sent to your email address
We have sent an email to your address. Please click on the link in this email to reset your password. If you can't find it in your inbox, please check your spam folder. If you can't find the email, please call us on 01-4199525.
ENTER YOUR LOYALTY CODE:
The reader loyalty code gives you full access to the site from when you enter it until the following Wednesday at 9pm. Find your unique code on the back page of Irish Country Living every week.
SHARING OPTIONS