DEAR EDITOR,

In June 2026, the latest EPA report on water quality again stated that there were widespread problems with water quality in Ireland, and that farming was the major cause, especially for nitrates.

Fortunately in July, the EU also released very detailed reports on progress under the Nitrates Directive for each country.

ADVERTISEMENT

Very comprehensive information was provided on nitrates in groundwater and in surface waters, and also on the ecological status of all surface waters.

Ireland fares relatively well

In stark contrast to the impression created by the EPA reports, and even more so compared to the views of many “expert” Irish commentators, water quality in Ireland stood out as markedly superior to that in most EU countries.

The international standard for nitrates for safe drinking water is 50 mg/litre. Only 1% of Irish ground water samples exceeded this threshold.

In contrast, 12.4%, 18.7%, 14.8% and 25.3% of French, Dutch, Danish and German samples, respectively, exceeded the 50 mg threshold.

The EU Nitrates Directive reports, plus a report from the European Environment Agency in September 2025, showed that the ecological status of rivers in Ireland was again far superior to those in most EU countries.

However, the EU has mandated that all surface waters in the EU must reach good ecological status by 2027. They originally set 2015 as the target date, but have now pushed the target date back to 2027, which they now say is immutable.

Zero

There is virtually zero chance that good ecological status can be achieved in most EU countries in the foreseeable future.

The EU mandate for good ecological status poses an almost existential threat to modern grassland and tillage farming in Ireland, and in much of the EU.

Even extensive grazing would be difficult in areas with challenging soils and topography.

Politicians will have a critical role, but non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and special-interest groups who have an ecocentric value system, and for whom biodiversity and ecological issues are top priorities, will try to move everything in their direction.

Clauses that may seem harmless or even benign (for example, a maximum nitrate level in rivers of 8mg/litre) can morph into regulations that can result in farmers operating with both hands tied behind their backs, or they can end up in planning tribunals or the courts, fighting a losing battle.

Critical decisions around the ecological status of Irish rivers will soon arise, and farmers and politicians must stay alert to the damage that unbalanced decisions can do.