It would be a “body blow” to the credibility of the EU’s green deal if the European Commission doesn’t match its ambition with increased funding for farmers, Minister for Agriculture Michael Creed has said.

“It is already clear that our farmers will be asked to deliver significantly more when it comes to achieving increased environmental ambition and I believe they are up for that challenge, but it is imperative that this higher level ambition is matched by appropriate funding,” he told the EU Agriculture and Fisheries Council on Monday.

Transition

ADVERTISEMENT

“It is difficult to see how a reduction in the CAP budget can be regarded as a just transition.

“I was reassured [by] Commissioner Timmermans and he made sure to make reference to and I quote ‘a sustainable future for our rural communities’ and spoke about this time of great transformation.

“But it is against those challenges that farmers are up for, that we are facing a 5% cut in the CAP budget and in particular a 15% cut in pillar II, which is the pillar which we use to develop appropriate environmental schemes that will enable us to meet that environmental challenge."

Talk is cheap, these actions cost significant money and will cost farmers money

“The question that is still not clear to me is whether Commissioner Timmermans is coming here with new money to assist us to do new things for the environment or whether he is coming with a great green new deal and telling us we must do all of this out of the existing resources which are proposed to be cut by 5%.

“I think that would be a body blow to the credibility to the green new deal if the Commission doesn’t recognise that its ambition has to be matched with appropriate levels of funding.”

Stretched budget

Minister Creed said Europe is piling additional demands in the green deal on top of an already stretched CAP budget without any additional funding being made available to the Commissioner for Agriculture to deal with such demands.

“And that’s an invidious position to put the commissioner in and it is a position that I think the Commission should reflect on. If it has ambition for a green new deal, that ambition has to be matched with appropriate resources.

“Talk is cheap, these actions cost significant money and will cost farmers money and if we are to meet the challenge of climate we have to resource those in the front line, those farmers, those rural communities appropriately to enable them to meet that ambition,” he said.

We must also ensure that the framework and the ambition are accompanied by an adequate budget

He said he thinks the future CAP can provide an adequate framework in order to accomplish the environmental ambition and we must ensure in our ongoing discussions that we maintain that level of ambition at the appropriate level.

“We must also ensure that the framework and the ambition are accompanied by an adequate budget,” he said.

Less climate efficient countries

Minister Creed also said that “deliberations on the implications for agriculture must therefore take account of a number of factors, including the need to support sustainable food production and to avoid outsourcing such production to countries that are less climate efficient than the European Union.

“It needs to take account of the limitations of available technology in agriculture and the role agriculture and land use management can play in carbon sequestration and the displacement of fossil fuels.

“It needs to take account of the critical role the CAP currently plays in supporting farm incomes, many of which are marginal. It also needs to take into account the need to incentivise climate action at farm level and to ensure a just transition,” he said.

Read more

IFA president Cullinan demands bigger CAP budget and end to climate hypocrisy

Year-end target for CAP

New CAP rules and green deal on EU agenda

CAP: Taoiseach pledges to protect farmers’ money