Good week/bad week: winners and losers in Irish farming
We take a look at who had a good week in farming and who had a week to forget.

It was a good week for…

  • Farmers who had cattle excessively trimmed at the factory, as Minister for Agriculture Michael Creed has said he understands a payment will be made to a farmer in any case where a trim fine was applied to a particular carcase.
  • Organic farmers, as Minister Andrew Doyle announced that organic payments will commence this week.
  • Young farmers, as payments through the Young Farmers Scheme (YFS) and the National Reserve have started to hit farmers' accounts.
  • Farmers claiming ANC monies, as the Department of Agriculture has proposed front-loading all ANC payment rates for 2019, favouring more disadvantaged areas and smaller farms.
  • It was a bad week for…

  • All farmers, as proposals to reduce the dominance of retailers and large processors in the agri-food industry will take some more "weeks" to be finalised.
  • Feedlot owners, as it emerged that 337 feedlots are locked-up with TB.
  • Cattle farmers in Northern Ireland, as an imported heifer from France was detected with Bluetongue.
  • Some 1,099 farmers, as they are facing water fines of up to €5,000 plus legal expenses for failing to sign up to an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) register.
    Ireland overtaken at the top of world food security rankings
    Singapore has overtaken Ireland at the top of the food security index with Ireland scoring highly for access to finance for farmers and nutritional standards.

    Ireland has been overtaken by Singapore as the most food secure country in the world. Last year, Ireland finished at the top of the Global Food Security Index for the first time.

    The index, which is published by The Economist Intelligence Unit, ranks countries based on food affordability, availability, and quality as well as an adjustment for natural resources and resilience. This new adjustment assesses a countries exposure to the impacts of a changing climate.

    The United States and the United Kingdom finished just behind Ireland in joint third position. It is the first year Singapore claimed the top spot. This was largely attributed to its status as a high-income economy where GDP per capita has risen nearly 30% since 2012 (when the index was first published).


    The index found Ireland had 16 strengths when it came to food security. The country scored 100% for presence of food safety net programmes, access to financing for farmers and nutritional standards.

    Food safety, food loss, sufficiency of supply and food consumption as a share of household expenditure were all ranked highly with Ireland scoring above 94%.

    Strengths were ranked as any metric above 75%. Coming in just above the 75% threshold were corruption, volatility of agricultural production and political stability risk. Volatility was the only metric where Ireland was ranked below the average of all other countries.


    Overall, 70% of countries included in the index recorded higher scores in 2018 with lower-middle- and low-income countries experienced the most substantial gains.

    Venezuela experienced the largest decline of any country. Analysts said: “As the economic crisis in Venezuela continues, the country’s food security situation has become critical… demonstrating the significant impact that political and economic insecurity has on a country’s food security.”

    Read more

    Ireland involved in new greenhouse gas emissions reduction action

    Why food isn’t viewed as a public good

    UK can unilaterally cancel its decision to leave the EU – ECJ
    The UK is free to revoke their decision to leave the EU without the permission of other EU member states.

    The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled that that Article 50, which signalled the UK’s intention to leave the EU at the end of March 2019, can be cancelled unilaterally.

    The ruling states the revocation of the withdrawal agreement “must be decided following a democratic process in accordance with national constitutional requirements”. This opens the door for a second referendum on whether the UK is to remain in or leave the EU.

    If such a vote were to take place and the decision to leave was revoked the ECJ said it confirmed; "EU membership of the member state concerned under terms that are unchanged as regards its status as a member state and brings the withdrawal procedure to an end."


    The European Council and Commission had contended that Article 50 could only be halted following a unanimous decision of the Council. This was due to the fear that allowing a country to withdraw from Article 50 unilaterally could be used as a bargaining chip in negotiations.

    The ECJ found that; “To subject that right to revoke to the unanimous approval of the European Council as the Commission and Council proposed, would transform a unilateral sovereign right into a conditional right and would be incompatible with the principle that a member state cannot be forced to leave the European Union against its will.”


    The UK government also tried to have the case declared inadmissible as the arguments presented are hypothetical given it is not their position to revoke Article 50.

    Speaking to the BBC, UK Agricultural Minister Michael Gove said the UK had no intention from halting the withdrawal process and called on MPs to support Theresa May’s deal.

    Read more

    UK can scrap Article 50 without EU permission says ECJ adviser

    Long read: 48 hours until Brexit chaos

    Weekly weather: up to 100mm of rain expected this week
    Met Éireann are predicting high rainfall levels for the majority of the country with the south west expected to receive almost 100mm.


    Today will begin mostly cloudy though a little hazy sunshine may occur for a time in the east. According to Met Éireann, other than scattered patches of drizzle or light rain mainly near west coasts and on hills, most areas will be dry. It will stay overcast through the afternoon and evening. After a cool start, temperatures will recover ranging 8°C to 12°C.

    Tonight will become quite windy with freshening southerly breezes. It will be predominantly dry but there will be a few patches of rain and drizzle about. Minimum temperatures of 5 to 9°C.


    Tuesday will see a dry day in many central and eastern counties. Rain will extend across most of Munster and Connaught by the afternoon. Rain will then gradually spread eastwards during the evening with some heavy bursts possible. Highest temperatures of 10°C to 13°C in moderate to fresh south to southeast winds.


    Rain and drizzle may linger across parts of east Leinster and Ulster on Wednesday but it will be largely dry elsewhere. However, another band of rain will reach the southwest coast by evening. This rain will extend nationwide on Wednesday night. Highest temperatures of 7 to 10°C.

    Thursday and Friday

    There remains uncertainty in the forecast detail for the end of the week but it looks set to stay unsettled.

    Farming forecast


    The last part of November and beginning of December were wet and this is reflected in the rainfall figures. Totals for the past two weeks are above normal almost everywhere. They were over twice the average values across the southern half of the country.

    For most places it will continue to remain wet in the week ahead with only the northwest having slightly less than anticipated normal levels. The southwest of Ireland will again be the wettest part of Ireland with rainfall amounts close to 100mm expected.


    Apart from the northwest of the country where temperatures were fractionally less than normal, all parts were positive by around a degree or so. This trend for positive mean temperatures will continue for the next week.

    Sunshine will continue to be close to normal for the time of year with weekly totals of around five to 12 hours.


    Drying conditions will be poor overall and opportunities for spraying will be very limited, if any. Given the high volumes of rain, land is very wet with many soils waterlogged.

    Read more

    Long read: northern exposure – sheep farming on the edge of Ireland

    Higher feed bills add to on-farm pressures